The Shocking Reality: The Demise of Freight Brokerages

The Shocking Reality: The Demise of Freight Brokerages

Table of Contents

  1. Introduction
  2. What is a Freight Broker?
  3. Why are Freight Brokerages Going Extinct?
    • 3.1 Increased Solicitation of Manufacturing Plants
    • 3.2 Fear of Non-Payment by Brokers
    • 3.3 Smarter Manufacturing Plants
    • 3.4 Carriers Becoming Smarter
    • 3.5 Decline in Personal Relationships
  4. Pros and Cons of Freight Brokering
  5. Conclusion

Why are Freight Brokerages Going Extinct?

In today's tumultuous market, the freight brokerage industry is facing unprecedented challenges. It seems like every day there's news of another brokerage company going out of business or declaring bankruptcy. But why are these freight brokerages being hammered the most? In this article, we will explore the reasons behind the slow extinction of freight brokerages and shed light on the factors contributing to their downfall.

1. Introduction

Freight brokers play a crucial role as intermediaries between shippers and carriers. Instead of taking possession of the freight, they facilitate communication and ensure the smooth handoff between the two parties. Their primary responsibilities include making sure the freight is transported safely and on time.

2. What is a Freight Broker?

Before delving into the reasons behind the decline of freight brokerages, let's first understand their role. A freight broker acts as a middleman, connecting manufacturing plants (shippers) with carriers. They secure manufacturing plants as customers and then distribute the loads to carriers. This concept allows shippers to focus on their core business while the broker handles the logistics.

3. Why are Freight Brokerages Going Extinct?

3.1 Increased Solicitation of Manufacturing Plants

One of the leading causes of the decline of freight brokerages is the relentless solicitation of manufacturing plants. In a struggling economy, manufacturing plants receive numerous solicitations from carriers, sometimes up to 10 to 15 times a week. This oversaturation has made manufacturing plants wary of working with freight brokers, as they fear non-payment by brokers could result in carriers going after them for payment, even if the manufacturing plant has already paid the carriers.

3.2 Fear of Non-Payment by Brokers

The fear of non-payment by brokers is another reason why freight brokerages are facing extinction. If a freight broker fails to pay a carrier, the carrier has the right to go after the manufacturing plant for payment, regardless of whether the manufacturing plant has already paid the carrier. This scenario forces manufacturing plants to consider using asset-based carriers instead of freight brokers to minimize the risk of financial disputes.

3.3 Smarter Manufacturing Plants

Manufacturing plants are becoming increasingly savvy and conscious of the markups imposed by freight brokerages. Many manufacturing plants have grown tired of brokerages making significant profits, sometimes ranging from 20% to 40% on loads they handle. To combat this, manufacturing plants are building their own databases of carriers, eliminating the need for intermediaries and ensuring they receive the most competitive rates directly from carriers.

3.4 Carriers Becoming Smarter

Carriers, too, have become more astute and are taking matters into their own hands. They have realized which manufacturing companies have regular freight needs and are proactively reaching out to them. Carriers are frustrated with brokerages that frequently fail to pay on time or make excuses to avoid paying waiting time or delays. They are opting to work directly with manufacturing plants, as asset-based carriers can often offer more competitive rates and reliable services.

3.5 Decline in Personal Relationships

As the new generation takes over the market, personal relationships are diminishing in importance. Traditionally, freight brokerages relied on wining and dining customers to foster loyalty. However, the younger generation, including traffic managers who hold positions for shorter periods, is less interested in personal favors or entertainment. Instead, they prioritize competitive rates and efficient service. The decline of personal relationships has further weakened the position of freight brokerages in the industry.

4. Pros and Cons of Freight Brokering


  • Access to a wide network of carriers
  • Expertise in managing logistics and ensuring smooth operations
  • Ability to negotiate competitive rates on behalf of shippers
  • Saves time and effort for manufacturing plants by handling logistics


  • Increased competition from asset-based carriers
  • Potential non-payment issues
  • Declining personal relationships
  • Higher markups on loads

5. Conclusion

The slow extinction of freight brokerages can be attributed to several factors, including increased solicitation of manufacturing plants, fear of non-payment, the rise of smarter manufacturing plants, carriers becoming more intelligent, and the decline of personal relationships. As the industry continues to evolve, freight brokerages will need to adapt and find innovative ways to stay competitive in an ever-changing marketplace.


  • Freight brokerages are facing extinction in today's market.
  • Increased solicitation of manufacturing plants and the fear of non-payment contribute to the decline.
  • Smarter manufacturing plants and carriers are opting for direct relationships.
  • Personal relationships with customers are becoming less influential.
  • The change in market dynamics calls for adaptation and innovation within the industry.


Q: What is the role of a freight broker? A: Freight brokers act as intermediaries between shippers and carriers, facilitating communication and ensuring the smooth transportation of freight.

Q: Why are manufacturing plants avoiding freight brokers? A: Manufacturing plants are hesitant to work with freight brokers due to the risk of non-payment, as carriers can legally pursue manufacturing plants for payment if brokers fail to pay them.

Q: How are carriers becoming smarter? A: Carriers are proactively approaching manufacturing plants directly, cutting out the middleman to offer more competitive rates and reliable services.

Q: Are personal relationships still important in the freight brokerage industry? A: Personal relationships are declining in importance as the younger generation prioritizes competitive rates and efficient service over favors and entertainment.

Q: What are the pros and cons of freight brokering? A: Pros include access to a network of carriers, expertise in logistics, negotiating competitive rates, and time-saving for manufacturing plants. Cons include increased competition, potential non-payment issues, declining personal relationships, and higher markups.

I am an ordinary seo worker. My job is seo writing. After contacting Proseoai, I became a professional seo user. I learned a lot about seo on Proseoai. And mastered the content of seo link building. Now, I am very confident in handling my seo work. Thanks to Proseoai, I would recommend it to everyone I know. — Jean

Browse More Content