The Importance of Links: Findings from Stone Temple Consulting Study

The Importance of Links: Findings from Stone Temple Consulting Study

Table of Contents

  • Introduction
  • The Importance of Links in SEO
  • The Core Part: Why Links Matter
  • The Myth of Content Marketing
  • Debunking Misleading Ranking Factors Studies
  • The Problem with Using Inaccurate Data
  • The Role of Total Links in SEO
  • Understanding Content Score and Its Limitations
  • The Role of On-Page SEO
  • The Relevance of Links to Content
  • Conclusion


In the world of SEO, there is an ongoing debate about the importance of links and their impact on ranking factors. This article aims to shed light on the topic and provide a comprehensive understanding of why links remain a crucial element in search engine optimization. While some argue that content marketing is the ultimate key to success, this article challenges that notion and delves into the significance of links in achieving higher rankings on Google. So, let's dive in and explore the role of links in SEO.

The Importance of Links in SEO

From the dawn of search engines, links have served as a fundamental ranking factor. Google, in particular, revolutionized the digital landscape by placing great emphasis on the quality and relevance of links. Despite the evolution of algorithms, links remain an integral part of Google's ranking criteria. The algorithm may have changed in terms of how it evaluates links, but their significance has not diminished. As an SEO expert, I firmly believe that links have always been and will continue to be a major determiner of website quality and authority.

The Core Part: Why Links Matter

Many SEO professionals argue that content marketing alone can yield desired results and diminish the importance of link building. However, my experience has shown otherwise. When it comes to competitive keywords and industries, solely relying on content creation can be incredibly inefficient and costly. While high-quality content is undoubtedly essential, it is often not sufficient to achieve top rankings. Google considers the trust and authority garnered through links as a vote of confidence from other reputable websites. Without links, a website's chances of ranking prominently for competitive keywords are significantly diminished.

Furthermore, Google has acknowledged the significance of links in their algorithm, even experimenting with search algorithms that exclude links. The results were nothing short of disastrous, highlighting the indispensable role of links in evaluating website quality. Therefore, it is crucial to recognize the importance of link building and incorporate it into any winning SEO strategy.

On the other hand, content marketing alone can prove to be an arduous and fruitless endeavor. It may take years to see tangible results, especially for businesses operating in highly competitive niches. The analogy of crawling from Dallas to New York perfectly encapsulates the inefficiency of relying solely on content marketing. While it is technically possible to reach the destination through crawling, it is slow, unreliable, and unlikely to get you to your goal. Similarly, content marketing can eventually yield results, but it is far from the most efficient path to success.

The Myth of Content Marketing

There is a prevailing narrative in the SEO community that content marketing is the holy grail of ranking higher on search engines. This misconception often leads businesses astray, wasting valuable resources on creating an abundance of content without considering other crucial factors. While high-quality content is undoubtedly valuable, it is not the sole determinant of ranking success. Google's algorithm takes into account various factors, including links, on-page SEO, and user engagement. Dismissing the importance of links in favor of content marketing is akin to embarking on a cross-country journey by crawling. It may get you there eventually, but the journey will be long, arduous, and largely ineffective.

Debunking Misleading Ranking Factors Studies

Numerous studies attempt to decipher the complex world of ranking factors, often claiming to identify the one path to SEO success. However, the reality is far more nuanced. Each website and industry may require a unique approach to achieve top rankings. There is no one-size-fits-all solution. The belief that adhering to a specific set of guidelines will automatically guarantee success is a fallacy.

SEO professionals, even among the best in the world, employ distinct strategies tailored to their specific goals. The SEO landscape is ever-changing, and what worked for one website may not necessarily yield the same results for another. Therefore, it is crucial to approach ranking factors studies with skepticism and not treat them as conclusive guidelines.

The Problem with Using Inaccurate Data

One common issue with ranking factor studies is the utilization of inaccurate data to draw conclusions. Take, for example, the use of Moz's data, which has been widely criticized for its lack of accuracy and slow crawling capabilities. Relying on such data skews the results and compromises the validity of the entire study. It is crucial to use reliable and up-to-date data to accurately assess the impact of various factors on rankings.

Furthermore, some studies employ total links as a metric, which is a highly flawed approach. Not all links are equal; their value varies significantly depending on the authority, relevance, and trustworthiness of the linking websites. Focusing solely on the quantity of links overlooks their qualitative aspects, resulting in a misleading understanding of their significance. Evaluating links should go beyond sheer numbers and prioritize quality and relevance.

The Role of Total Links in SEO

While the emphasis should be placed on quality rather than quantity, total links still play a crucial role in SEO. Building high-quality, relevant, and authoritative links to a website can significantly improve its visibility and ranking potential. However, it is imperative to avoid over-optimization, as this can lead to penalties from search engines. Striking the right balance and ensuring a natural link profile is vital for long-term success in SEO.

Understanding Content Score and Its Limitations

Some studies introduce the concept of content score, which attempts to quantify the quality of content. However, measuring content quality is subjective and cannot be accurately gauged by a single metric. Content relevance and engagement play substantial roles in determining its quality. Google assesses the user's interaction and behavior on a website to gauge its value. If visitors spend a significant amount of time on a site, it indicates relevant, engaging content. Conversely, if users quickly bounce back to search results, it signifies subpar content. It is crucial to recognize that content score alone cannot capture the essence of high-quality content.

The Role of On-Page SEO

Contrary to popular belief, on-page SEO factors are far from obsolete. Titles, URLs, and interlinking undoubtedly contribute to a website's relevance and authority. Ignoring these elements can significantly hamper a site's ranking potential. Google considers these factors as signals that help determine a page's relevance to a given search query. While content is undoubtedly an integral part of SEO, it should not overshadow the importance of on-page optimization.

The Relevance of Links to Content

The notion that links are irrelevant if content is highly competitive or relevant is misleading. In reality, links can bolster the relevance and visibility of any content, regardless of competition. It is not uncommon to find pages with minimal or no visible content still ranking prominently due to strong link profiles and proper on-page optimization. Therefore, it is essential to embrace a holistic SEO strategy that incorporates both high-quality content and effective link building.


In conclusion, the persistent importance of links in SEO cannot be understated. They remain a crucial ranking factor that distinguishes websites and determines their trustworthiness and authority. While content marketing has its merits, relying solely on content creation is an inefficient path to success. SEO success lies in striking the right balance between high-quality content and effective link building. By understanding the multifaceted nature of SEO, businesses can navigate the ever-evolving digital landscape and achieve long-term ranking success.


  • The significance of links in SEO cannot be overstated.
  • Content marketing alone is insufficient for ranking success in competitive industries.
  • Link building is an integral part of any winning SEO strategy.
  • Beware of misleading ranking factors studies and the misuse of inaccurate data.
  • Total links play a crucial role, but quality and relevance are paramount.
  • Content score should not be the sole metric for content quality evaluation.
  • On-page SEO factors still hold relevance in determining website ranking.
  • Links enhance the relevance and visibility of any content.
  • A balanced SEO strategy combines high-quality content and effective link building.


  1. Q: Are links still important for SEO in 2021?

    • A: Yes, links remain a crucial ranking factor in SEO. They signify trust and authority and contribute significantly to a website's visibility and ranking potential.
  2. Q: Can content marketing alone guarantee high rankings on search engines?

    • A: While high-quality content is vital, relying solely on content marketing is an inefficient approach. Effective link building is necessary for achieving top rankings, especially in competitive niches.
  3. Q: How do on-page SEO factors contribute to website ranking?

    • A: On-page SEO factors, such as titles, URLs, and interlinking, provide signals to search engines regarding a page's relevance. Optimizing these elements enhances a website's ranking potential.
  4. Q: Do total links matter more than the quality of links?

    • A: No, the quality and relevance of links are more important than their sheer quantity. Building high-quality, authoritative links is crucial for improving a website's ranking and authority.


I am an ordinary seo worker. My job is seo writing. After contacting Proseoai, I became a professional seo user. I learned a lot about seo on Proseoai. And mastered the content of seo link building. Now, I am very confident in handling my seo work. Thanks to Proseoai, I would recommend it to everyone I know. — Jean

Browse More Content